Fisch Witch Rewards – Fischfright Witch Ingredients!

What are the Fisch Witch Rewards? You can get them by finding ingredients for the cauldron. Another part of the Fischfright 2025 event is the Fisch Trick or Treating feature! Don’t miss out on the Halloween-exclusive rewards in Fisch.

Fisch Witch Rewards

Collect Witch ingredients and bring them to the cauldron to obtain rewards! If you don’t know how many ingredients you need to find for the next reward, one of the dialogue options when speaking with the Witch NPC lets you check. This way, you can plan when collecting the ingredients, without wasting time travelling to and from Crook’s Hallow.

Rewards from the Witch’s Cauldron

What can you get when bringing ingredients to the Witch’s Cauldron?

Eyeball Bobber
Requires 1 Witch Ingredient
Coffin Lantern
Requires 3 Witch Ingredients
Gravestone Bobber
Requires 5 Witch Ingredients
Ghost Title
Requires 8 Witch Ingredients
Spooky Rod
Requires 10 Witch Ingredients
Ghost Bobber
Requires 12 Witch Ingredients
1 Frightful Relic
Requires 15 Witch Ingredients
Candy Title
Requires 20 Witch Ingredients
1 Spooky Relic
Requires 25 Witch Ingredients
1 Eerie Relic
Requires 30 Witch Ingredients
Spider Bobber
Requires 40 Witch Ingredients
Pumpkin Title
Requires 45 Witch Ingredients
Dutchman’s Spirit Boat
Requires 55 Witch Ingredients
Zombie Title
Requires 65 Witch Ingredients
Wisp Flame Lantern
Requires 75 Witch Ingredients
Blazed Handle
Requires 100 Witch IngredientsThis is a required item for the fourth Jack-o-Blazer quest, which you need to give to the Headless Horseman NPC
Reborn Flying Dutchman Boat
Requires 175 Witch Ingredients
Witch’s Broom Boat
Requires 250 Witch Ingredients

Witch Location

Unlike the Fischfright event in 2024, you cannot find the Witch NPC on Moosewood Island. Instead, you need to head over to the Flying Dutchman NPC who stands atop the boat of the same name. When speaking to him, he offers to teleport you to Crook’s Hallow, which is the Fischfright 2025 limited-time island.

Once you teleport here, you can find the Witch standing by her cauldron, surrounded by pumpkins, candles, and cobwebs. Each time you collect one of the Witch’s ingredients, you can head back to the cauldron in Crook’s Hallow and interact with the cauldron to place the ingredient inside. When you reach each milestone, you obtain rewards!

The post Fisch Witch Rewards – Fischfright Witch Ingredients! appeared first on Gamezebo.