Fisch Trick or Treat Rewards – Scylla’s Mask and Candy Buckets

The Fisch Trick or Treat feature is a big part of the Fischfright 2025 event, especially when collecting event-exclusive fish and relics! These catches count as some of the rarest fish in Fisch.

Fisch Trick or Treat

Go trick or treating in Fisch!

How to Trick or Treat

To take part in the Trick or Treating activity during the Fischfright 2025 event, you need to equip a Candy Bucket! Once you have a Candy Bucket, you can wander around Crook’s Hallow (the event-exclusive location) and knock on the doors of the various houses.

As with the nature of Trick or Treating, when an NPC opens the door after you knock, they’ll either say Trick or Treat!

Treat

There is a 55% chance for the NPC to say Treat! If you have the Scylla Mask, the chance increases to 66%. As well as Candies, you also obtain a random fish or Relic from the Trick or Treating reward pool.

Possible Trick or Treat Rewards

Eerie Relic
0.27% drop chance0.32% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Frightful Relic
0.27% drop chance0.32% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Spooky Relic
0.27% drop chance0.32% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Baby Nessie
0.67% drop chance0.80% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Lollipop Lamprey
5.35% drop chance6.42% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Gummy Guppy
6.69% drop chance8.03% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Marshmallow Mackrel
8.03% drop chance9.64% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Licorice Leech
9.37% drop chance11.24% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Candy Corn Cod
10.71% drop chance12.85% drop chance with Scylla Mask
Caramel Chub
13.38% drop chance16.06% drop chance with Scylla Mask

Trick

There is a 45% chance for the NPC to say Trick! With the Scylla Mask, this decreases to 34%. For Tricks, you still get Candies as a reward, but you do not get any of the catches or Relics from the Trick or Treating reward pool.

How to Get the Scylla Mask

You can purchase the Scylla Mask from the Flying Dutchman NPC during the Fischfright event 2025. It costs a total of 1.5K Candy! This is the main currency for the event and can be used to purchase a variety of other items, too. To get Candy, you can Trick or Treat, complete Fischfright quests, put ingredients in the Witch’s Cauldron and open Frightful Crates.

To find the Flying Dutchman NPC, all you need to do is visit Moosewood and look for him! By speaking to this NPC, you can also teleport to and from Crook’s Hallow.

The post Fisch Trick or Treat Rewards – Scylla’s Mask and Candy Buckets appeared first on Gamezebo.